A pool in the basementUpper West Side

The Upper West Side townhouse with a 41-foot indoor pool

A 140-year-old Upper West Side townhouse hides a 41-foot heated indoor pool on its own downstairs level, complete with spa, steam shower, and skylight. Back on the market at $10.45 million after a $1 million cut, it is the rare townhouse that comes with its own resort.

10/17/2026

A 140-year-old Upper West Side townhouse with a 41-foot heated indoor pool on its own downstairs level is back on the market at $10.45 million, after a $1 million price cut. The house at 238 West 74th Street spans 6,460 sqft across five levels, with five bedrooms and 6.5 baths, two elevators, a private garden, and a terrace. The pool level holds a steam shower and spa, a wet bar and dressing room, radiant-heated floors, and a skylight that brings daylight down to the water. A private indoor pool is a rare amenity even in Manhattan hotels, and in a townhouse it is rarer still.

The house was commissioned in 1886 by Jacob Lawson from the builder and architect William J. Merritt, whose row houses helped define the Upper West Side's streetscape. The brick and brownstone facade is Neo-Grec, and it remains intact behind a landscaped garden, in the heart of the West End-Collegiate Historic District. Merritt built the house as a speculative row house in a neighborhood that was still filling in, and 140 years later the facade is the part of the house that has changed least. The interiors, by contrast, have been rebuilt twice over.

There is no middle ground with a 41-foot pool in the basement.

The transformation began in the cellar, where the pool, spa, and an additional elevator were added, and a full interior renovation followed in 2020, bringing a new kitchen and bathrooms, floating staircases, tile floors, heated floors, and a generator. The kitchen is stocked with Wolf, Viking, and Bosch appliances, the parlor floor holds two living areas with a fireplace and wet bar, and the five bedrooms sit on the upper levels, including a south-facing suite with a private terrace. The whole house is wired with video security, integrated audio, and automatic shades. What the renovation produced is a house that reads as historic from the street and operates as a new building inside.

The pool is the story, and it is worth asking why it works. Private pools in Manhattan townhouses are scarce because the cellar space they require is scarce, and the engineering, a heated 41-foot lap pool with a spa under a skylight, is the kind of amenity that usually belongs to a hotel or a club. Here it belongs to one household, on a level of its own, and the listing agent's pitch is that it turns the house into a private retreat for swimming year-round. The $1 million cut suggests the market needed persuading, but the pool is the kind of feature that either finds its buyer immediately or waits for one. There is no middle ground with a 41-foot pool in the basement.

The American Museum of Natural History stands a short walk away, and the house sits between Broadway and West End Avenue, moments from Riverside Park and the 72nd Street express subway. The townhouse pairs the two things the Upper West Side sells best: a landmarked street and a modern interior, with a resort spa underneath. At $10.45 million it is priced for a buyer who wants townhouse privacy and scale, loves to entertain, and intends to swim every day of the year.