The Upper East Side townhouse in Tiffany's holiday film is for sale at $13.2M
The limestone townhouse at 57 East 74th Street, offered at $13.2 million with Brown Harris Stevens, played a supporting role alongside Amanda Seyfried in Tiffany & Co.'s new holiday film. The 1901 Buchman and Deisler house has sat on the market since January, and Tiffany just gave it the best advertising a townhouse can get.
Christmas came early at 57 East 74th Street. The Upper East Side townhouse had a supporting role alongside Amanda Seyfried in Tiffany & Co.'s new holiday campaign, Love Is a Gift, whose short film You & Me follows family memories across generations and marks Seyfried's debut as a Tiffany House ambassador. The house is listed with Brown Harris Stevens' Joyce Sheena, and the brokerage's own account of the film is disarmingly direct: you really could not pick a more quintessentially New York property. A luxury brand with a century and a half of taste behind it chose this house to stand in for New York itself.
The house earns the casting. Designed by Buchman and Deisler and built in 1901, the Neo-Classical limestone residence sits on a historic landmark block between Madison and Park Avenues, behind ornate iron grille entry doors that are one of the firm's signature elements. Inside are original oak wainscoting, intricate plasterwork, and inlaid wood floors, with a parlor level that rises to 12-foot ceilings. The residence offers 16 rooms across five floors and a fully finished lower level, including seven bedrooms, six and a half bathrooms, nine fireplaces, and two private outdoor spaces, in just over 8,200 sqft of interior space. It is a house that was built to receive, and a century later it still photographs like one.
Offscreen, the townhouse has its own plot to resolve. It is offered at $13.2 million, and the ask was trimmed by $700,000 in May, from $13.9 million. The listing has been active since January 2026, and a tenant is in place until December 31, 2026. That is the unglamorous half of the story: a handsome, well-preserved house on one of the Upper East Side's best blocks has waited eight months for a buyer, and the film arrived in the middle of that wait. The question is whether a starring role in a Tiffany campaign does what eight months of open houses did not.
The street has always done half the selling. East 74th Street between Madison and Park is the kind of block where the architecture is the amenity: limestone facades, landmark protection, and a scale that has not changed since the house was built. The Frick Collection sits a short walk up Fifth Avenue, its own Gilded Age house turned museum, which is the closest comparison for what 57 East 74th Street is selling — a private house with the bones of a public one. Buyers at this level are not buying square footage; they are buying a block, a pedigree, and a set of rooms that have already survived one full century of fashion.
The decode is that the film and the listing are selling the same thing. Tiffany chose the house because it reads as New York on camera: the iron doors, the oak, the plaster, the nine fireplaces, the patina that cannot be staged or bought new. The listing's real asset is the same one Tiffany rented for a day, and the campaign hands the seller something no broker can buy — a national audience that has now seen the parlor level in a holiday film and will remember the house long after the commercial ends. A $13.2 million townhouse with a tenant until New Year's Eve is a complicated purchase; a $13.2 million townhouse that America just watched Amanda Seyfried walk through is a simpler story to tell.