The last Gilded Age mansion on 57th Street sells for $42M — and faces demolition
The Schieffelin-Bowne House, an 1891 Beaux-Arts mansion that began as a Vanderbilt wedding gift, has sold for $42 million to the developer assembling Billionaires' Row. Demolition plans are already approved — and the preservation campaign to save its facade is running out of time.
The Schieffelin-Bowne House at 35 West 57th Street, a five-story Beaux-Arts mansion from 1891, has sold for $42 million. The Soloviev Group sold it to the developer Sedesco in a deal that closed October 29, 2026, according to city property records — the final piece of an assemblage on which Sedesco has now spent nearly $290 million. Demolition plans for the mansion have already been approved by the city's Department of Buildings, though no timeline has been confirmed, and the developer has not said what will rise in its place.
The house began as a wedding gift. Margaret Vanderbilt Shepard gave it, fully furnished, to her daughter Maria Louise Vanderbilt Shepard and her new husband, William Jay Schieffelin, when they married in February 1891. The couple lived in the five-story house through the 1890s, and in 1899 it was sold to the businessman Samuel W. Bowne, whose name it still carries. It was a gift from the richest family in America, on a street the Vanderbilts practically owned — Cornelius Vanderbilt II's mansion stood just down the block at One West 57th Street.
The twentieth century was not kind to it. The first two floors were converted to retail, the ornament weathered, and the neighboring townhouses to the east were demolished this March, leaving the house standing alone against its neighbor. Preservation advocates behind the Save57 campaign call it the last surviving Gilded Age mansion on West 57th Street, and they are urging Sedesco to keep its historic facade in whatever rises next. The house is not landmarked, and the retail conversion may have cost it the Landmarks Preservation Commission's protection — the commission did not respond to a request for comment.
What comes next is a supertall. Earlier proposals for the site envisioned a 63-story tower of about 1,100 feet, with 119 condominium residences, a 158-room hotel, and a restaurant. Sedesco, which began assembling the site in 2012, says it will unveil updated plans in the coming months. The mansion is the last holdout in the assemblage, and the sale reads as the final step before the wrecking ball — the same arc that took the Hotel Pennsylvania, demolished for a plan that then stalled, as Commercial Observer notes.
The sale is the news; the street is the piece. Millionaires' Row became Billionaires' Row one mansion at a time, and this was the last of the originals still standing on 57th Street. Whether its facade survives the tower is now a question for the developer, the preservationists, and the city — and the answer will say something about what New York is willing to keep.