Two homes in an 1893 houseProspect Heights

196 Saint Marks Avenue, two condos in an 1893 Prospect Heights house

Two four-bedroom condos inside a restored 1893 building at 196 Saint Marks Avenue in Prospect Heights are priced at $4,995,000 for the garden home and $4,500,000 for the upper home — after the sponsor raised both prices in a September amendment, before either home went into contract. The offering plan was accepted in May, and the first closing is targeted for January 1, 2027.

11/03/2026|196 Saint Marks Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11217

Two four-bedroom condos inside a restored 1893 building at 196 Saint Marks Avenue in Prospect Heights are priced at $4,995,000 for the garden home and $4,500,000 for the upper home. The sponsor raised both prices in a September amendment, before either home went into contract. The offering plan was accepted by the Attorney General on May 1, 2026, and the renovation and first closing are targeted for on or about January 1, 2027. Neither home is listed publicly yet.

The two homes split the house by level. The garden home runs over three levels — cellar, first and second floors — at about 3,200 sqft including a 1,010-sqft cellar, plus a 491-sqft private rear yard. Its first floor is one open living and dining room across the back of the house, with steps down to the yard, and the primary suite takes the back of the second floor. The upper home, on the third and fourth floors, is about 2,560 sqft with a 1,082-sqft private roof terrace, four bedrooms and four full baths. Together the two homes run to 5,760 sqft, about $1,650 a foot — or about $2,000 a foot excluding the garden home's cellar, which the offering plan says cannot be used as a bedroom or living room.

The block is the argument for the price.

The building is a careful conversion of an 1893 four-family house in the Prospect Heights Historic District, preserving its historic character while giving the systems and layouts a full modern reset. It is a brownstone-scale walk-up with no elevator, which is the point as much as the constraint: two residences, no shared amenities, no lobby, no staff. The sponsor, 196 Saint Marks LLC, acquired the building in 2025 for $3.36 million and filed the offering plan that January. The plan was accepted in about four months, faster than most, and the September amendment raised the garden home from $4.8 million and the upper home from $4.25 million.

The pricing has a direct precedent one block over. At 189 Prospect Place, between Carlton and Vanderbilt, the same play ran on a landmarked townhouse: two condos, a larger garden home with the yard and a smaller upper home with outdoor space, no elevator and no shared amenities. The garden home asked $4.25 million, was trimmed to $4.199 million, and closed at $4 million in July 2024 after 158 days. The upper home asked $3.5 million and closed at $3.45 million in June 2024 after 66 days. On stated square footage, the two homes traded at roughly $1,413 a foot. At 196 Saint Marks the ask is about $1,650 a foot, roughly 17 percent higher, with four bedrooms in each home instead of three.

The pattern is the thing to watch. At 189 Prospect Place the big garden unit was the harder sell: a price cut and 158 days, while the upper home was gone in 66. At 196 Saint Marks the garden home is again the more expensive of the two, and the sponsor raised its price before a single contract. If the pattern repeats, the negotiating room is downstairs.

The block is the argument for the price. Saint Marks Avenue sits a short walk from Grand Army Plaza and the northwest corner of Prospect Park, with the Brooklyn Museum, the Public Library, and the Botanic Garden all within a few blocks, and the B and Q at 7th Avenue about four minutes away. Prospect Heights is the most central piece of brownstone Brooklyn, and a two-home conversion on one of its prettiest blocks is the borough's version of a boutique building: small, historic, and priced like it knows it.