The second-largest house in AmericaHuntington

Oheka Castle, America's Gatsby estate, goes for $72M at auction

Seven bidders, 740 prospects, and a $72 million winning bid for the 127-room château Otto Kahn built fireproof on an artificial hill — a house that has been a Gatsby model, a military academy, and a film set, now waiting on a judge.

10/27/2026|135 West Gate Drive, Huntington, NY 11743

Oheka Castle, America's Gatsby estate, goes for $72M at auction

On Tuesday, October 27, a live auction at The Dominick hotel in Manhattan drew seven bidders and a winning bid of $72 million, plus a buyer premium, for the second-largest private residence ever built in America. Oheka Castle — 127 rooms, about 113,000 sqft, on 23 acres on the highest point on Long Island — is pending sale, subject to bankruptcy-court approval. It is the first time in a century that the house has changed hands at anything like a public price, and the number is about half the $137 million an appraiser put on it.

The house was built between 1914 and 1919 for Otto Hermann Kahn, the financier and arts patron whose initials spell its name: O-H-E-K-A. Kahn built it after Jews were barred from clubs and golf courses in Morristown, New Jersey, and after a fire nearly destroyed his previous country home — so he had Delano & Aldrich design it in steel and concrete, one of the first totally fireproof residences, and spent two years building the artificial hill it stands on, for views of Cold Spring Hills and Cold Spring Harbor. The Olmsted Brothers laid out the formal French gardens. The original 443-acre estate held an 18-hole golf course by Seth Raynor, one of America's largest private greenhouse complexes, tennis courts, an indoor pool, orchards, stables, and a landing strip, and more than 100 full-time staff kept it running.

A house built as a rebuke to exclusion, filmed as the ultimate American fantasy, and rescued once from ruin.

After Kahn's death in 1934, the house lived several other lives: a retreat for New York City sanitation workers, then Eastern Military Academy from 1948 to 1979, then four years empty, during which it survived more than 100 documented arson attempts — the fireproofing holding, as designed. Developer Gary Melius bought the ruin in 1984 for $1.5 million and spent about $40 million restoring it, the largest private residential restoration in American history, recreating the gardens from the original Olmsted plans. The house became a hotel, a wedding venue, and a film set in the same decade: photographs of Oheka stood in for Xanadu in Citizen Kane, and it later hosted Taylor Swift's "Blank Space," Succession's boar hunt, and a century of weddings.

The auction came out of a Chapter 11 case Melius's company filed in July 2025 to stop a foreclosure, with about $64 million owed to creditors. The winning bidders, Ronald Browning and Paul Alflen of Gold Coast Property & Estate Management, say they will leave the castle as it is and keep its historical presence; the sale also carries a neighboring parcel already approved for 95 luxury condominiums, which they have not said whether they will build. Booked weddings are to be honored through at least March 2028. A house built as a rebuke to exclusion, filmed as the ultimate American fantasy, and rescued once from ruin now waits on a judge to decide whether its next chapter is preservation or development.