The post-election breather, decoded
Manhattan signed 189 contracts in the week of November 9 to 15, the fewest since early October and a sharp pullback from the record week before, but the shelf kept thinning and the pipeline into December closings kept building. The week was a breather, not a turn.
Manhattan took a breath in the week of November 9 to 15, after the strongest week of the fall. The borough signed 189 contracts, down 23 percent from the week before and 12 percent below the same week last year, the fewest since early October, according to the Howard Hanna NYC weekly update. The pullback follows a week of 245 contracts, the most since mid-June. One softer week after a surge is not a turn, but it is a reminder that the late-fall window is narrowing, with Thanksgiving less than two weeks away.
The supply side kept tightening while contracts cooled. Active inventory fell to 5,897 homes, down 1.6 percent in the week and 9.7 percent from a year ago, a third consecutive weekly decline and the lowest count since late September. New listings totaled 221, down 6 percent in the week and 12 percent from last year, an eighth straight weekly decline and the lowest since the start of September. New listings are down more than 60 percent from their mid-September peak of 560, and inventory has fallen by about 260 homes in three weeks. The shelf buyers see now is likely the widest they will find until spring.
The pipeline into year-end closings kept building even as new contracts slowed. Pending sales rose 0.9 percent to 2,995, the highest since mid-September, as the strong late-October and early-November contract weeks work their way toward closing. Thirty-day supply sat at 1,107 against a November norm of 960, and contract activity was still running above its November norm of 830. A soft week of signings does not mean a soft December: the closings that land next month were mostly signed in the weeks that came before.
October's closed sales show the same two-speed market the weekly numbers keep describing. Sales under $1 million fell 10 percent from a year earlier, while sales at $4 million and above rose 9 percent, and Brooklyn showed the same pattern. Mortgage rates ended the week at 7.50 percent, and the Howard Hanna sentiment index for Manhattan slipped from plus 25 percent to minus 2 percent. The one segment that accelerated was new development: 35 contracts across 27 buildings in the week of November 9, up from 29 the week before and the busiest week of the fall, according to Marketproof.
The decode is that the market is easing into its seasonal year-end pattern, not changing direction. Fewer new listings, a gradually thinning shelf, and a contract count that moves week to week around a still-healthy pace. For buyers, the week offered a little breathing room, and sellers who have been on the market since September may be more open to negotiation. For sellers, competition from new listings is the lightest since early September, which favors the homes that are priced right now. The next two weeks will show whether the surge or the pullback is the better guide to how the year finishes, and the shelf says the choice on offer now is the widest until spring.