New York's price cuts now total $1.22 billion
A daily scan of New York listings found 5,371 active price cuts totaling $1.22 billion, up from $1.14 billion two weeks earlier. The average cut is 7.4 percent, and the cuts are the market negotiating one listing at a time — sellers anchored to 2021 peak prices meeting buyers anchored to 6 and 7 percent rates. The total is not a crash; it is the bill for asks that priced for a market that no longer exists.
New York's active price cuts now total $1.22 billion. That is the sum of asking-price reductions across 5,371 listings in a scan run November 7, and it is the widest view of a softening Erik has been watching listing by listing. The number sounds like a crash. It is not. It is the price of a gap, between sellers anchored to 2021 and 2022 peak prices and buyers anchored to 6 and 7 percent mortgage rates and higher tax bills, and the gap is being negotiated one listing at a time.
The scan behind the number is a daily sweep of 16,497 active New York listings across 130 neighborhoods, run by Luxury Price Drops, an independent analytics platform that tracks asking prices on Zillow. On November 7 it found 5,371 listings carrying a cut, 258 of them added in the previous 24 hours. The average reduction is 7.4 percent. The deepest is 60.2 percent. The largest single cut is $15 million. Two weeks earlier, on October 23, the same scan counted 5,068 cuts totaling $1.14 billion. The total has grown by about $80 million in a fortnight, not because the market fell but because more sellers decided their ask was the problem.
The platform's own read is that cuts of 5 to 12 percent are common on $3 million to $10 million Manhattan condos, and that a cut of 15 percent or more is real distress. That distinction is the decode. Most of the $1.22 billion is not distress. It is sellers who listed at 2021 prices into a 2026 market and are now meeting it halfway, in increments. The cuts are discrete, a price change here and a relisting there, rather than the broad repricing a faster market would force. A market that reprices listing by listing is a market still arguing with itself.
The other half of the argument is in Corcoran's October report, published the same day. Manhattan sellers who actually closed gave up an average of just 1.0 percent from their last asking price, the smallest discount since 2022. Put the two numbers together and the market splits in two. Price the apartment right and it sells at the ask. Price it at the peak and it joins the 5,371, cutting a little at a time until a buyer appears. The $1.22 billion is not the market falling. It is the bill for the listings that priced for a market that no longer exists.
That is why the number matters less as a total than as a direction. The count is rising, 5,068 to 5,371 in two weeks, and the reductions are widening. Sellers are learning the new price in public, one cut at a time, and buyers are watching the scan the way they once watched open houses. The next number to watch is not the total. It is whether the cuts start to shrink, which would mean the asks have finally caught up with the bids.