The architect's own house

Middlefield: the Hudson Valley estate Gil Schafer built for himself is back at $6.5 million

Middlefield, the 45-acre Hudson Valley estate that classical architect Gil Schafer built for himself in 1999, is back on the market asking $6.5 million. It sold in July 2025 for $6.18 million, nearly $2.7 million above ask, and returns with a new roof, new mechanicals, and Schafer's room arrangements intact.

10/17/2026

Middlefield, the 45-acre Hudson Valley estate that the classical architect Gil Schafer built for himself from the ground up in 1999, is back on the market asking $6.5 million. The Greek Revival country house at 895 County Road 83 in Amenia sold in July 2025 for $6.18 million, nearly $2.7 million above its original asking price of $3.5 million, and returned to the market in late September with Compass broker Ashley Whittaker. The relisting comes with a new roof, overhauled mechanical systems, and newly sourced antique wood floors throughout, and the current owners have kept Schafer's original room arrangements intact.

Schafer is one of the country's leading practitioners of classical architecture, and Middlefield was both his home and his portfolio piece. He built the roughly 4,000 sqft residence from scratch as a demonstration of his firm's core idea: new construction engineered to appear centuries old, with the proportions, millwork, and patina of a house that had been standing for generations. The double-height portico on classical columns anchors the exterior, and inside a central hall connects three bedrooms and four bathrooms, with a kitchen in cream cabinetry, butcher-block counters, a wood-burning fireplace, and a butler's pantry. Landscape architect Deborah Nevins designed the formal gardens that frame the rolling fields and mature trees.

A house that sold for its provenance can sell again for its rooms.

The 2025 sale is worth pausing over, because it says something about what the Hudson Valley market now rewards. A house listed at $3.5 million in May sold in July for $6.18 million, a premium of nearly 80 percent over ask, driven not by square footage but by provenance: a house designed by a named architect, built to his own standard, on 45 acres with gardens by a named landscape architect. Homes with genuine architectural provenance routinely command premiums far beyond comparable square footage in the region, and Middlefield's bidding war was the pattern at its most extreme. The $6.5 million relist, barely above the 2025 sale price, is the market digesting that premium rather than chasing it further.

Between the July closing and the October listing, the estate's new owners finished the third floor and the lower level, adding a media room and a private study upstairs and expanding the utility areas below grade, while preserving the original millwork, wide-plank flooring, and antique mantels. Schafer parted with Middlefield after his marriage to the interior designer Courtnay Daniels, telling ELLE Decor in May 2025 that the couple wanted a home they could shape together rather than one conceived entirely by one partner. He auctioned much of the original furniture before the sale, and the summer buyers retained his spatial arrangements and decorative vision. The house that returns to market is Schafer's house, updated by owners who understood what they had bought.

Middlefield sits in Amenia, in Dutchess County, about two hours from Manhattan, and this draft is filed with that geography flagged: the site has published beyond the five boroughs before, including the Red Hook estate, when the architecture justified the trip. A Greek Revival house that an architect built for himself, sold in a frenzy, and returned to market three months later is such a case. The question the relisting answers is whether a house that sold for its provenance can sell again for its rooms, and the $6.5 million ask is the first test of that.