Manhattan luxury revs up with 36 inked deals
Buyers signed 36 contracts at $4 million or more in the week of October 19 to 25, the most since the first week of June, with $292 million in asking volume and eight trophy deals.
Manhattan's luxury market had its strongest week in twenty weeks. Buyers signed contracts for 36 homes asking $4 million or more in the week of October 19 to 25, according to Olshan Realty's weekly report, the most since the first week of June, which also logged 36, and up from 28 the week before. The deals totaled $292 million in asking volume, an average of $8.1 million and a median of $6.1 million, and eight of them were trophy properties. Of the 36 homes, 19 were condos, 13 were co-ops, and four were townhouses. The typical home spent more than a year on the market and was discounted 5 percent.
The top of the week tells the story in miniature. Penthouse D at 255 East 77th Street, a six-bedroom, six-bathroom full-floor condo of 5,520 sqft with two terraces in Robert A.M. Stern's 62-unit tower, found a buyer at a $23.75 million ask after about five months on the market. Sales at the building launched in September 2024, and all but one residence has now sold or entered contract; the one remaining penthouse asks $37.5 million. The week's second deal, Unit 59A at 53 West 53rd Street, a 3,762-square-foot three-bedroom sponsor condo above the Museum of Modern Art, went into contract at $21.53 million on the same day it was listed, a same-day deal that suggests an off-market arrangement. The building has been selling its 161 units since 2015, through price cuts, a change of sales team, and arbitration with its developers.
The decode is in the mix, not just the count. Condos outsold co-ops 19 to 13, a narrower gap than usual, and co-ops averaged $6.8 million against $9.4 million for condos, which says buyers are taking on prewar co-ops, and the renovations that come with them, to get the location and the layout. The week's highest co-op contract was a 1925 five-bedroom at 860 Park Avenue asking $10.95 million. And the week landed three months into the pied-a-terre surcharge, the tax on second homes that was supposed to chill the top of the market: instead, the strongest luxury week since June. About 55 percent of owners who received a tax bill have appealed it, according to The City, and the rollout is still being litigated. The buyers, for now, have priced the tax in or decided the address matters more.
The supply side explains why the pace may hold. Manhattan inventory stood at 6,132 homes, down 0.4 percent, and 252 new listings arrived, down 14 percent, while the 30-year fixed mortgage rate sat at 7.24 percent. Agents describe inventory down almost 30 percent this fall, and high-end rentals in bidding wars pushing renters into buying. One week is not a trend, and contracts are not closings. But after months of slower luxury contracting, a 36-deal week with eight trophies, led by the Upper East Side and carried in part by co-ops, is a pace change, and it says the buyers who waited through the summer and the tax headlines are buying now.
