The tax that did not stop the top tier

Manhattan luxury booms as buyers shrug off the pied-à-terre tax

Thirty-six contracts were signed at $4 million and above in the week reported October 26, the strongest luxury week since early June, four months after the pied-à-terre tax took effect. The top tier is treating the levy as a cost of admission, not a reason to wait.

10/26/2026

Manhattan's luxury market had its strongest week since early June, and it did so with a new tax hanging over every second home in the borough. Thirty-six contracts were signed at $4 million and above in the week reported October 26, eight more than the week before, according to the Olshan luxury report. The Upper East Side led the borough, and condos outsold co-ops by a narrower margin than usual, 19 to 13. The week's top contract was a six-bedroom penthouse at 255 East 77th Street, asking $23.75 million. The numbers arrive four months after the pied-à-terre tax took effect on July 1, and they read as a shrug.

The tax itself is not small. For second homes held as condos or co-ops, the annual surcharge runs 4 percent on fair market value of $1 million to $3 million, 5.25 percent from $3 million to $5 million, and 6.5 percent at $5 million and above, and it is set to run until June 30, 2031. The rollout has been troubled, with delays and legal challenges, and about 55 percent of owners who received a tax bill have successfully appealed so far, according to The City. A buyer at the top of the market is therefore not only weighing a 6.5 percent annual charge but a system that is still being litigated and, in many cases, beaten on appeal.

There is a price to being in Manhattan, and people consider it worth paying.

So why is nobody waiting? The brokers in the Realtor.com report point to the same answer: there is almost nothing to buy. Douglas Elliman's Michelle Griffith says Manhattan inventory is down almost 30 percent this fall, and that the shortage runs across all price points. Rents, meanwhile, are so high that they are pushing people into buying. Griffith says high-end apartments that once rented for $25,000 a month are now drawing bidding wars at close to double that, and families who would rather rent are being forced into a buying market with slim pickings. Her advice to clients has become blunt: if an apartment checks seven of ten boxes, move forward, because the perfect one is not coming.

The psychology underneath is the decode. Compass broker Michael Reisor, who recently sold a $4.5 million NoHo loft condo as a pied-à-terre, says buyers may trim their budget a little but will not give up the home they want, and quotes one townhouse owner who looked for something cheaper because of the tax and then bought what he actually wanted anyway. Reisor's line is that there is a price to being in Manhattan, and people consider it worth paying. The escape routes are also narrowing: California is weighing a billionaire tax and Washington state has a millionaires tax taking effect in January 2028, so a buyer looking for a lower-tax refuge has fewer obvious places to go.

The honest read is that the tax has been priced in, not priced out. At the top of the market, a 6.5 percent annual surcharge on a second home is a carrying cost to be absorbed, the way a buyer absorbs common charges or a renovation budget, and the week's 36 contracts suggest the absorption is already happening. What would change the math is not the rate but the uncertainty: the appeals record, the December court cases challenging the tax itself, and whether the bills now going out survive contact with the courts. Until one of those breaks the other way, the luxury market's message is plain. Scarcity, not the surcharge, is setting the pace, and buyers would rather pay the tax on the home they want than wait for a market that may never get cheaper.