A $27.5 million penthouse, bought for $13 million
Scarlett Johansson and Colin Jost paid $13 million for the triplex penthouse at 1220 Park Avenue in March 2025, less than half its original 2018 asking price of $27.5 million. The 6,000-square-foot, six-bedroom home in a 1930 Rosario Candela building had been on and off the market for seven years. The sellers had paid the same $13 million for it in 2006. The apartment's price never fell. The ask did.
A $27.5 million penthouse sold for $13 million, and the gap is the story. Scarlett Johansson and Colin Jost paid $13 million for the triplex at 1220 Park Avenue in March 2025, less than half the $27.5 million it first asked in 2018. The six-bedroom, 6,000-square-foot home had been on and off the market for seven years, and by the end of 2024 the price had fallen to less than half the original figure. The sellers had paid the same $13 million for it in 2006. Nineteen years, and the apartment's price never moved. Only the ask did.
The apartment is the kind that does not come up often. Penthouse B at 1220 Park Avenue is a three-level residence with six bedrooms, seven bathrooms, five terraces and eight balconies, in an 18-story Rosario Candela building from 1930 on the corner of East 95th Street, in Carnegie Hill. The listing described a 14-room triplex with a curved staircase, a galley kitchen, six wood-burning fireplaces and 65 windows. The terraces look over Central Park. It is the sort of prewar penthouse that was built for a different kind of New York, and it is also the sort that now takes seven years to sell, because the buyer for it is rare and the price has to find them.
The price history is a lesson in what an ask is. In 2018 the apartment was listed at $27.5 million, a number that assumed the market of 2015 would return. It did not. The apartment came on and off the market for seven years, the price falling in increments, until by the end of 2024 it had dropped below half the original ask. The buyers paid $13 million — the same figure the sellers had paid in 2006. The sellers broke even across nineteen years, and the buyers bought a Candela triplex for its 2006 price. Nobody lost money on the apartment itself. The $27.5 million was never the apartment's price. It was a wish, and the market spent seven years saying no to it.
That is the decode, and it is why the story belongs on artfully rather than in a gossip column. The celebrity names are the hook, but the price is the piece: a prewar penthouse whose value held flat for nineteen years while its asking price doubled and then halved. The Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum, stands a few blocks south at 2 East 91st Street, a reminder that Carnegie Hill's value was never the asking price — it is the architecture, the park, and the museums that have been there for a century. A Candela triplex with five terraces does not need a $27.5 million ask to be worth having. It needs a buyer who sees what it is.
The buyers saw it. Johansson and Jost had been looking for a larger home in the city since 2022, and the 1220 Park penthouse is the kind of apartment that rewards patience on both sides: the sellers waited seven years for a buyer at the right price, and the buyers waited for a prewar triplex that had finally stopped pretending to be worth twice what it was. The apartment sold for what it was worth in 2006, and what it is worth now. The $14.5 million between the ask and the sale was never real money. It was the cost of asking too much, for too long.