The captain's flag

The Revolutionary War captain's house in Sag Harbor, and the flag that may predate the Stars and Stripes

A house built between 1780 and 1790 by Revolutionary War captain John Hulbert is on the market in Sag Harbor asking $19.5 million. A homespun flag found in his barn in 1926 may predate the official Stars and Stripes, and historians are still arguing about it.

10/18/2026

A house built between 1780 and 1790 by a Revolutionary War captain is on the market in Sag Harbor asking $19.5 million. The house at 241 Main Street was built by Lieutenant Colonel John Hulbert, who captained the 3rd New York Regiment from 1775 and served as a magistrate and storekeeper in the village. It is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, and it stands on Captain's Row, the stretch of Main Street where the village's sea captains built their homes. The house has been substantially remade since Hulbert's day, but the bones of an 18th-century captain's house remain under the cedar shingles.

Hulbert's claim to fame came long after his death. In 1926 a homespun woolen flag was found in a barn he owned near the Triangle Commons in Bridgehampton, bearing stars and stripes in a pattern similar to the design adopted as the national flag in 1777. A local historian posited that the flag was designed by and for Hulbert's Bridgehampton militia, which would make it older than the official Stars and Stripes design attributed to Francis Hopkinson. There is no conclusive evidence either way, and the relic, now held by the Suffolk County Historical Society Museum, remains an open question. A plaque outside the Sag Harbor house states the claim with more confidence than the evidence supports, which is itself a small piece of American history.

A plaque outside the house states the claim with more confidence than the evidence supports.

The house as it stands is a Colonial Revival composition in cedar shingle with white trim, a wraparound porch, and three crowned dormer windows at the top level. It spans about 4,000 sqft across three levels, with an open great room, a new kitchen organized around a center island, and glass doors opening to the rear garden. The grounds hold a bluestone terrace and a 40-foot pool, and a 1,000 sqft guest house by Steven Gambrel stands on the lot. A prior owner completed a full gut renovation and annexed a neighboring lot for the guest house, and the interiors now pair exposed beams and wide-plank floors with a double-height glass wall in the great room.

The house last traded in 2022 for $12 million, according to property records, and the current listing comes from Sotheby's International Realty. The sellers are recorded as a limited partnership, and the price history is a matter of public record rather than private gossip. What the $19.5 million ask buys is not just 4,000 sqft on 0.65 acres but a documented place in the Revolution, a National Register listing, and a flag story that historians are still arguing about. Few houses at any price carry that combination.

The house stands on Captain's Row, where the captains' homes now sit beside the village's galleries and shops, a short walk from the waterfront. Sag Harbor is outside New York City, in Suffolk County, and this draft is filed with that geography flagged: the site has published beyond the five boroughs before, including the Old Westbury house and the Red Hook estate, when the story was strong enough to travel. The Hulbert house qualifies on its own terms, a captain's house with a flag in a museum and a plaque that may be telling the truth.