Brooklyn Heights goes ultra-luxury as the 1909 Hotel Bossert becomes a Ritz-Carlton
Marriott and developer SomeraRoad will convert the 1909 Hotel Bossert at 98 Montague Street into the Ritz-Carlton Residences, Brooklyn Heights, the borough's first branded condos, with a 2029 finish. The announcement caps a decade of false starts for the landmark hotel and a post-pandemic run-up that has turned Brooklyn Heights into one of the city's most contested markets.
The splashiest sign of Brooklyn Heights' transformation sits at 98 Montague Street. In September, Marriott International and developer SomeraRoad revealed plans to turn the 14-story Hotel Bossert, a 1909 Renaissance Revival landmark where the Brooklyn Dodgers toasted their 1955 World Series win, into the Ritz-Carlton Residences, Brooklyn Heights. Owners get a round-the-clock attended lobby, wellness and entertaining amenities, and Marriott portfolio perks, while Danny Meyer's Union Square Hospitality Group opens its first full-service Brooklyn restaurant on the ground floor. Construction is expected to start later this year, with a 2029 finish; Ryan Serhant's firm is handling sales, and prices are not yet available.
The road to this announcement was long. The Jehovah's Witnesses sold the building to Joseph Chetrit and David Bistricer for $81 million in 2012, with plans for a boutique hotel. The reopening was pushed back again and again, and a planned fall 2017 debut as the Esplendor Bossert never happened. Chetrit defaulted in May 2022 owing as much as $126.7 million, and a 2023 rescue attempt by Ian Schrager and Ed Scheetz fizzled. Beach Point Capital took it at an uncontested foreclosure auction in February 2025, then sold it to SomeraRoad for $100 million that May. The Ritz-Carlton flag is the first plan in over a decade with a brand and a balance sheet behind it.
The conversion lands where almost nothing comes up for sale and almost everything sells over ask. Corcoran broker Deb Rieders told the Post that prices have risen sharply since the pandemic, when Manhattanites sought more space without giving up an easy commute, and that nearly every co-op and condo between $1 million and $5 million sparks a bidding war. The recent sales back her up: a two-bedroom at 89 State Street listed at $1.67 million in September closed in October for $1.9 million, while another at 75 Poplar Street sold within a week for $125,000 above its $1.65 million ask. Neighborhood-wide, homes go into contract in a median of 45 days at a median sale price of about $1.77 million, and an off-market Civil War-era townhouse at 192 Columbia Heights closed for roughly $25 million, the priciest Brooklyn sale of the year so far.
The Ritz is not the only newcomer betting big on the neighborhood. A few blocks away, the 52,000 sqft Kings Athletic Club opened this fall at 43 Clark Street, in the base of the Hotel St. George co-op, with tennis courts, pickleball, a pool, squash courts, and golf simulators; a source told the Post that annual memberships run $30,000 to $70,000, with a waitlist already forming. Landau Properties broke ground this summer on One Montague Place at 205 Montague Street, a 50-story tower with 46 condos, 90 rentals, and 40,000 sqft of retail, with units reported from $6 million. The Center for Brooklyn History sits a few blocks away on Pierrepont Street, a reminder that the district's cultural life predates the velvet rope.
The decode is in the brand, not the building. Boldface buyers arrived long ago: Matt Damon set a borough record with a $16.7 million penthouse at the Standish; Emily Blunt and John Krasinski followed with an $11 million full floor there. What is new is the infrastructure of ultra-luxury arriving all at once — a Ritz-Carlton flag, a five-figure athletic club, a 50-story tower — in a landmark district protected from development by law, which is why the scarcity premium keeps compounding. SomeraRoad's founder Ian Ross called it Brooklyn's premier residential address. The question is whether a small-town-feeling place can absorb the velvet rope without losing what made it desirable.