The Dakota spread, cut from $39M to $12.5M after a decade
Residence 84 at the Dakota, a 6,000 sqft spread assembled over three decades from four apartments, dropped to $12.5 million on September 21, roughly a third of the $39 million it asked in 2016. The listing has lingered for a decade, and the building's landmark status is part of why: any renovation needs Landmarks Preservation Commission approval on top of the co-op board's. The broker's answer is a new floor plan by designer Elena Frampton, reimagining the spread as a modern five-bedroom home.
Residence 84 at the Dakota dropped to $12.5 million on Monday, September 21, roughly a third of the $39 million it asked when it first came on the market in 2016. The 6,000 sqft spread spans the entire eighth floor of the building at 1 West 72nd Street, with what listing broker Ben Dixon calls more Central Park frontage than any other home in the Dakota. It has been on and off the market for a decade, and the latest cut, from $13.9 million in May, extends a slide that has now erased $26.5 million from the first ask.
The home was assembled, not bought. Tribeca Festival co-founders Jane Rosenthal and Craig Hatkoff spent more than three decades and 20 separate transactions stitching four apartments into a single residence, with dormer windows, wood-burning fireplaces, and arched doorways. Rosenthal, Robert De Niro's longtime producing partner, and Hatkoff, a real estate investor, divorced in 2014 after 19 years of marriage and still own the apartment jointly. Over the years it was the site of entertainment-industry and literary gatherings. The sale also includes a separate 400 sqft unit across the hall, with three windows and its own bath, which had asked $15 million on its own last year.
The building is the constraint. The Dakota, completed in 1884 to Henry J. Hardenbergh's design, is a New York City landmark, so any renovation must pass the Landmarks Preservation Commission in addition to the co-op board, and brokers have said that double approval is part of what has kept the listing lingering. The New-York Historical Society, a museum, sits five blocks north on Central Park West.
The listing broker has answered with a drawing rather than a discount alone. Ben Dixon of Douglas Elliman commissioned designer Elena Frampton, after conversations with the building's own architect, John Wender, to reimagine the spread as a modern five-bedroom home with ensuite baths, subject to board approval. The listing pitches the apartment as a rare chance to craft a legacy home of remarkable scale, the foundation for what could become one of the most important homes on the park.
The cut is the story, and it is a market story as much as a Dakota story. At $12.5 million the spread asks just over $2,000 per square foot, a figure that would have been unthinkable for a Central Park West trophy a decade ago, and the discount from the first ask now totals $26.5 million. The Dakota has outlasted every owner and every price, and the question the listing now asks is whether a buyer wants its grandeur enough to take on the landmark process that comes with it.