A landmarked Lenox Hill townhouse cuts to $4.999 million after 19 months on the market
The four-story townhouse at 243 East 61st Street asks $4.999 million after a $500,000 cut, down from just under $7 million when it first listed in April 2025. The house spans about 5,000 sqft in Lenox Hill's Treadwell Farm Historic District, and the latest cut finally takes it below the $5 million line it has been circling for months.
The landmarked townhouse at 243 East 61st Street asks $4.999 million, after a $500,000 cut that finally takes it below $5 million. The four-story house spans about 5,000 sqft in Lenox Hill's Treadwell Farm Historic District, a pocket of mid-to-late 19th-century brownstones between Second and Third avenues. It first listed in April 2025 at just under $7 million, and it has been on and off the market ever since, returning each time a little cheaper. The listing is the peg, but the arithmetic is the piece: nearly $2 million has come off the ask in about 19 months.
Treadwell Farm is one of the city's earliest landmarked districts, a run of three- and four-story brownstones along East 61st and 62nd streets that the Landmarks Preservation Commission protected and that joined the National Register of Historic Places in 2004. The houses were built in the mid-to-late 19th century, when Lenox Hill was filling with the rowhouses that still set the rhythm of the side streets. The district's protection is the point for a buyer: the streetscape cannot be casually remade, and the house's neighbors will look much the same in a decade as they do now. The house itself was built in 1905, in the brownstone idiom the district preserves.
The path to $4.999 million has been a long one. The house first listed in April 2025 at $6.99 million, dropped to $6.75 million that July, and was pulled from the market in December. It returned in January 2026 at $6.75 million, dipped to $5.99 million at the end of April, reappeared in August at the same price, and slipped to $5.49 million in September before this latest cut. Each return has been marketed as a fresh start, most recently with reimagined interiors, and the listing's own pitch is that there is very little in the Upper East Side townhouse market this substantial, this flexible, and this well-positioned at this price. The sub-$5 million line is the message: the house is no longer competing as a $7 million townhouse, but as the cheapest substantial house in its district.
What the money buys is five bedrooms across four stories, with three full bathrooms and two powder rooms, and a floor plan the listing says can be adjusted, so the bedroom count is a starting point rather than a fixed fact. The listing pitches the house as an opportunity to preserve what works and improve what matters, which is the honest language for a house that needs a buyer's vision as much as their checkbook. A four-story townhouse of about 5,000 sqft under $5 million is a rarity on the Upper East Side, and the rarity is the listing's whole argument: the price has finally fallen to meet the house, rather than the house rising to meet the price.
The Asia Society Museum, at Park Avenue and 70th Street, is a short walk north. That is the read on the cut: a landmarked house, priced at last for the market it actually sits in, on a block the city has agreed not to change. The next buyer gets the district's protection and the house's bones, and the $2 million of patience it took to get here is now priced in.