From garage to grand houseUpper East Side

Bunny Mellon's garage: the $80 million carriage house on East 70th Street

A limestone carriage house on East 70th Street that once served as Paul and Bunny Mellon's private garage is on the market asking $80 million. Designed in 1902 by C.P.H. Gilbert and reborn in 2011 as a 15,978 sqft home, it is a century of Upper East Side history in a single facade.

10/23/2026

A limestone carriage house on East 70th Street that once sheltered the cars of Paul and Bunny Mellon is on the market asking $80 million. The house at 165 East 70th Street was designed in 1902 by C.P.H. Gilbert for the banker Henri P. Wertheim, and in 1920 it was reimagined as a garage with chauffeur's quarters for Stephen C. Clark, whose grandfather co-founded the Singer Sewing Machine Company. The Mellons used it later as their private garage, and in 2011 the Sawyer|Berson firm turned the building into a 15,978 sqft home with 20 rooms. Few listings carry a provenance quite like this one: a working garage for two of America's great collectors, rebuilt as a turnkey mansion.

Gilbert was the architect the Gilded Age called when it wanted a limestone facade that would outlast the fortune behind it. His Upper East Side houses set the tone for the blocks around East 70th Street, where stone fronts, tall windows, and restrained classical detail became the neighborhood's signature. The house at 165 East 70th Street is landmarked, and its Neo-Italian Renaissance front has survived every one of its reinventions intact. What changed was never the face of the building, only what happened behind it.

A garage for the Mellons was never just a garage.

The garage years are the story. Paul Mellon was one of the great American art patrons, a collector whose gifts built whole wings of the National Gallery of Art in Washington, and Bunny Mellon was the horticulturalist who designed the White House Rose Garden during the Kennedy administration. Their cars lived here while their collections shaped museums, and the building's second life as a garage is a reminder that the Upper East Side's grandest houses were once supported by a whole infrastructure of service buildings. A garage for the Mellons was never just a garage; it was a small piece of the machinery of American collecting.

The 2011 renovation made the building a house again, and an extravagant one. Sawyer|Berson kept the limestone shell and rebuilt the interior around a 46-foot iron and limestone staircase that rises to a skylight, with six bedrooms, 13 baths, three landscaped terraces, a solarium, and six wood-burning fireplaces. The lower level holds a spa with a Jacuzzi and cold plunge, steam room, sauna, and massage room, and there is a 13-seat soundproof theater, a gym, and an eat-in chef's kitchen. Heated floors run from the kitchen to the terraces and out to the sidewalks, and the listing agent calls the house completely turnkey.

The Frick Collection sits a short walk away on East 70th Street, and the block itself reads like a catalog of the neighborhood's collecting history. The house is the rare listing where the architecture, the owners, and the art all point the same way: a Gilbert facade, a Mellon garage, and a 2011 interior built to museum standards of finish. At $80 million it is priced as a landmark, and in a sense it is one, a building that spent a century moving between the city's great patrons and now waits for its next owner.