Below ask on Fifth AvenueUpper East Side

Lenox Hill penthouse sells for $14.9 million

A penthouse at 880 Fifth Avenue closed at $14.9 million against a $15.8 million last ask, a below-ask deal in Emery Roth's 1948 tower, the first postwar building on Fifth Avenue.

10/28/2026|880 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10075

The top home sale to hit the records on October 28 was a penthouse at 880 Fifth Avenue, which closed at $14.9 million against a last asking price of $15.8 million. The four-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bathroom co-op was listed by Brown Harris Stevens, and the $900,000 gap between ask and close, a discount of just under 6 percent, is the number that matters. On Fifth Avenue, even the grand addresses now trade with a negotiation attached.

The building is the reason the sale is worth more than a line in the records. 880 Fifth Avenue, on the northeast corner of 69th Street, was completed in 1948 as the first apartment building on Fifth Avenue after the Second World War and the last building designed by Emery Roth, the architect behind many of the city's most famous residential towers. The 21-story, 160-unit co-op is the only twin-towered building on the avenue, its limestone facade mildly Art Deco with classical touches, built for the developers Percy and Harold Uris on the site of two Gilded Age mansions. It stands directly across from the Frick Collection, with the Metropolitan Museum of Art further north on Museum Mile, and its apartments were laid out with a more open plan than the prewar norm, a postwar idea of luxury that has aged into classicism.

What endures is the address.

The below-ask close fits the quarter the building sits in. Manhattan closings of $8 million and above fell by about a quarter in the third quarter, according to Howard Hanna's analysis of deed records, while the $5M-to-$8M band carried the growth, and the typical luxury contract in the last week of October was discounted 5 percent after more than a year on the market, according to Olshan Realty's weekly report. A penthouse at 880 Fifth Avenue is not a distressed asset; it is a grand apartment selling into a market that now expects a discount at the top. The building's own recent history makes the point: its grandest penthouse, a 3,350-square-foot residence with a wraparound terrace and a double-height foyer, sold for $22 million in September 2023, when the top of the market still closed at ask.

What endures is the address. Roth's postwar Moderne was designed to sell at a profit to an upscale clientele and to fit in among the classical buildings around it, and it has done both for nearly eighty years. A penthouse here buys into that run: a limestone tower with twin turrets on the park, a doorman, a garage, and a place in the long line of Fifth Avenue apartments that were built to last. The price is the market's verdict on the moment. The building is the reason the verdict is still $14.9 million.