328 West 89th Street, the 'You've Got Mail' townhouse, lists for $3.95 million
The 1894 Renaissance Revival rowhouse at 328 West 89th Street — the exterior of Kathleen Kelly's home in You've Got Mail — is listed for $3.95 million by Leslie J. Garfield, an eight-bedroom, nine-bath townhouse of 5,885 sqft that still draws fans to its stoop.
The stoop at 328 West 89th Street has been photographed more than almost any other private stoop in the city, and nobody who stops there lives in the house. It is the exterior of Kathleen Kelly's home in You've Got Mail, the 1998 film that made the Upper West Side the most romanticized neighborhood in America — and the house behind the stoop is now for sale, listed October 23 for $3.95 million.
The film is the reason the address is famous. Nora Ephron directed You've Got Mail and wrote it with her sister Delia; Ephron, a former New York Post writer, had already written When Harry Met Sally, and the two films together fixed the Upper West Side in the popular imagination as the place where bookshops, brownstones, and autumn leaves did the talking. Meg Ryan's Kathleen Kelly ran the Shop Around the Corner, the independent children's bookshop, and her apartment — this house, shot from the outside — was where the film's private half happened. The listing leans into the role outright, calling the house the "You've Got Mail" townhouse, and the broker, Richard Pretsfelder of Leslie J. Garfield, told the Post that superfans still stop by on tours to take a photo or two. "People really love the movie and they love the house," he said.
The house earns the attention on its own merits. It is an 1894 Renaissance Revival rowhouse in brick and limestone, five stories over a basement, with limestone parlor and basement stories, terra-cotta trim around the bay windows, and arched windows on the fourth floor. Inside are the details the listing leads with: high ceilings, bay windows, parquet floors, six fireplaces, exposed red brick, a curved staircase, an original stoop, and a private garden.
The numbers are the quiet surprise. Eight bedrooms and nine baths across 14 rooms and 5,885 sqft, configured today as an owner's duplex plus six other residential units — a buyer can keep the seven-unit setup or reconfigure the house as a single-family home. At $3.95 million, the ask works out to about $671 per sqft, a number that reads less like a premium for fame than like a price for the conversion. The fame, in other words, is not what the seller is charging for.
That is the honest way to read the listing. Film fame is a fragile asset — it belongs to a movie, not to a deed — and the market here is pricing the house, not the poster. What the buyer gets is an 1894 rowhouse on a tree-lined Upper West Side block, with a garden and six fireplaces, that happens to be the most photographed stoop in the neighborhood. The movie made the address; the address has to carry itself from here.