Everett Shinn's old townhouse returns on Washington Square North at $19.995M
The townhouse at 26 Washington Square North, built in 1839 for Produce Exchange vice president William Dare Morgan and later home to Ashcan School painter Everett Shinn, is back on the market at $19.995 million. It is the highest townhome on the north side of the park, one of the last privately owned houses on the Row, and currently configured as five leased floor-through apartments.
A once-in-a-lifetime opportunity is how the listing puts it, and on Washington Square North the claim is close to literal. The townhouse at 26 Washington Square North, a five-story landmarked Greek Revival house built in 1839, is back on the market at $19.995 million. It sits as the highest townhome on the north side of the park, with approximately 8,750 sqft of interior living space, ten bedrooms and thirteen baths, and it is currently configured as five floor-through luxury apartments, all of them leased. The house was gut renovated in 2018, and the building, the block, the park, and the surrounding neighborhood are all protected as part of the Greenwich Village Historic District.
The house was built for William Dare Morgan, vice president of the Produce Exchange, a partner in Grinnell, Tinker and Morgan, a governor of the Knickerbocker Club, a founder of New York Hospital, and a Yale graduate. He and his wife Angelica Livingston Hoyt, a descendant of two of the signers of the Declaration of Independence, raised four children in the house. The Morgans built it as a four-story home with a gated forecourt, ornate fencing, an elevated stoop, a formal columned entrance portico, and a paneled door with sidelights and a transom, and they added a fifth floor in 1880. Their family remained in the house for over half a century, a run of single-family continuity that the house has not matched since.
The later owners read like a cross-section of old New York: former silent movie executive Richard West Saunders, well-known attorney John Pinkerton East, the financier Charles V. Bob, and the painter Everett Shinn. Shinn is the name that matters to this site. A member of the Ashcan School, he painted the city as it actually looked — the theater district, the street, the crowd — and a house that looks straight across Washington Square Park at the arch would have suited a painter who never looked away from New York. Edward Hopper painted the square too, and the park has fed painters, writers, and musicians for more than a century.
The house belongs to the Row, the group of Greek Revival houses along the north side of Washington Square Park flanking lower Fifth Avenue, built for the social elite of the Village in the 1830s. What remains of the Row is now recognized as one of the most outstanding series of Greek Revival houses in the country, sought after for a uniform architectural style, high quality construction, extra deep lots, prominent stoops, formal entrance porticos, and generous front gardens and forecourts. The listing's own history makes the point: these houses were built as a set, and they survive as a set, which is why the north side of the park still reads as a single composition nearly two centuries on.
The pitch is optionality, and the numbers explain why. A buyer can keep the five leased apartments and collect the income, live on a floor or two and keep the rental income from the rest, or convert the house back to a single-family residence: the architect firm Ingui Architecture has designed a conversion the listing calls one of the most spectacular park-facing townhouses in the city, with plans subject to Department of Buildings and Landmarks Preservation Commission approvals. The property can be delivered vacant, with tenants in place, or as a live-work combination, with no rent stabilization. That is the decode: a $19.995 million house that is also a rental business, on park frontage that cannot be reproduced, in a district where nothing like it can ever be built again.