The wine cave staysCobble Hill

168 Pacific Street, an 1830s Greek Revival townhouse rebuilt as a private club, returns at $15.6 million

After four months at $16.65 million, the townhouse at 168 Pacific Street relisted September 24 at $15,600,000. Behind its Greek Revival facade in the Cobble Hill Historic District sits a complete rebuild: six elevator-accessible levels, 6,306 sqft, a cellar wine cave and gym, and a penthouse suite with skyline views. The cut is the peg; the house the rebuild made is the piece.

11/07/2026

The townhouse at 168 Pacific Street is back at $15.6 million, down from $16.65 million after four months on the market, and the cut changes the question the house asks. At the higher figure it was a provocation, a Greek Revival shell rebuilt to private-club standard in a neighborhood that guards its quiet. At $15.6 million it is still a commanding ask for its block, but the number now reads as an invitation to look at what the rebuild actually is: six elevator-accessible levels, 6,306 sqft, a wine cave and a gym in the cellar, and a penthouse suite with skyline views at the top. The listing relisted September 24, and the price is the peg; the house behind its old facade is the piece.

Cobble Hill is the right setting for that kind of patience. The neighborhood grew up in the mid-1830s, when rows of Greek Revival townhouses went up on what had been farmland, and it still reads as one of the most intact 19th-century residential districts in the city. The Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the Cobble Hill Historic District in 1969, and the district was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1976. The oldest house still standing in the district, at 122 Pacific Street, dates to 1833 or just before, a near neighbor on the same street. A house here joins a streetscape protected for more than half a century.

Cobble Hill does not sell square footage by the pound; it sells a protected streetscape.

What makes 168 Pacific Street unusual is how thoroughly the interior has been remade while the street face stays in period. The listing describes a complete transformation by Peter Guthrie's Yellowtrees Studio, with all-new mechanical systems, structural enhancements, and waterproofing built on passive house principles for energy efficiency. The restoration work is historically correct where it shows: restored windows, a new front stoop, cornice, and ironwork, and dramatic rear and rooftop additions that open the house to the garden and the sky. A private elevator connects all six levels, from the cellar to the penthouse, so the house reads as one continuous home.

Inside, the parlor level does the entertaining in true brownstone style, with a light-filled double-height great room, a kitchen in pale wood with quartz and marble worktops, and a terrace leading down to the landscaped rear garden. The garden level holds a guest suite, a media room, and a large family room that flows out to the garden. Two upper floors are the private quarters, including a full-floor primary suite with a dressing room, a marble bath with a fireplace, and a private terrace. At the top, the penthouse suite has skyline views in every direction, room for a home office or entertaining, and a bedroom with a full bath, flowing into two roof decks. Down in the cellar, the private-club comparison earns its keep: a gym, a sauna, a wine cave, a wet bar, and laundry.

That is the honest way to read the $1.05 million cut. Cobble Hill does not sell square footage by the pound; it sells a protected streetscape, a short walk to Brooklyn Heights and the waterfront, and houses nearly two centuries old. The rebuild at 168 Pacific Street bets that a buyer will pay for both at once: the 1830s facade the district protects, and the new house behind it, with its elevator, its passive-house systems, and its cellar wine cave. Four months at the higher ask tested the top of that bet. The lower ask tests whether the house itself, rather than the number, can close the gap.