An 1873 townhouse, remadeUpper East Side

126 East 73rd Street, an 1873 townhouse remade by Benjamin H. Webber in 1912, lists for $14.5 million

Built in 1873 in the Italianate style, the five-story house at 126 East 73rd Street was transformed in 1912 by architect Benjamin H. Webber into its present neo-Elizabethan form. Now listed at $14.5 million in true move-in condition, it is a house with two birthdays, and the second one is the face it shows the street.

11/07/2026

The five-story townhouse at 126 East 73rd Street asks $14.5 million, listed November 5 by Compass and presented in true move-in condition. Five bedrooms and six and a half baths sit across about 6,250 sqft, with a 1,130 sqft finished basement below and a 720 sqft private landscaped garden with a fountain behind it. The address is a prime tree-lined Lenox Hill block between Park and Lexington avenues. The listing is the peg, but the architecture is the piece: this is a house with two birthdays, and the second one is the face it shows the street.

The first birthday is 1873, when the house went up as an Italianate rowhouse. The Italianate brownstone was the standard product of the speculative builders filling the Upper East Side in the 1870s, a run of tall parlor windows, bracketed cornices, and stoops climbing to the parlor floor, built street by street as the neighborhood grew north from the older districts downtown. The houses were built to a pattern, and the pattern is what still gives the blocks their rhythm. What survives of 1873 at 126 East 73rd Street is the bones: the five-story shell, the lot, and the address itself.

A buyer is paying for the 1912 face and the 1873 bones together, a house that has already been remade once and kept ever since.

The second birthday is 1912, when architect Benjamin H. Webber transformed the Italianate rowhouse into its present neo-Elizabethan form. Neo-Elizabethan was the Tudor vocabulary of brick, stone trim, and steep gables borrowed from Elizabethan England, and Webber's remaking gave the house an entirely new face. The Landmarks Preservation Commission record describes it plainly: an Italianate rowhouse built in 1873, altered in the neo-Elizabethan style by Benjamin H. Webber in 1912. It was a busy year for such remakings on the Upper East Side; Landmarks records show another townhouse nearby, designed by Thom & Wilson, was altered by Hiss and Weekes the same year.

The house today is the product of both dates. Five stories of living space, the finished basement, and the garden with its fountain add up to a turnkey house in a landmark-protected district, the Upper East Side Historic District, where the streetscape cannot be casually remade again. The Frick Collection, at 1 East 70th Street, is a short walk away. The listing stresses that the house has been impeccably renovated and meticulously maintained by its current owners, and the move-in condition claim is the point: nothing here needs the next owner's imagination, only their furniture.

That is the honest way to read the $14.5 million ask. A buyer is paying for the 1912 face and the 1873 bones together, a house that has already been remade once and kept ever since. The first owners bought a pattern-book Italianate rowhouse; the second act made it something distinct, and the district's landmark protection now holds that act in place. Townhouses this layered rarely come to market in move-in condition, and this one arrives with its history written on its facade: built in one century's taste, remade in another's, and still standing on the same Lenox Hill block.