The filed price meets the marketTribeca

111 Murray penthouse deal leads Manhattan luxury contracts

Penthouse 1 at 111 Murray Street closed at $31M, the priciest Manhattan deal of the week of October 26 to November 1 — about 38 percent below the $50M the developers filed in the offering plan, the same discount the tower's other penthouse took.

11/02/2026|111 Murray Street, New York, NY 10007

The last penthouse at 111 Murray Street closed on October 26 for $31M, and the deal was the priciest Manhattan contract of the week of October 26 to November 1, according to Olshan Realty's weekly report. Penthouse 1, a five-bedroom, six-bathroom home of about 7,700 sqft with terraces totaling more than 230 sqft, sold for roughly $4,000 per sqft. The closing also marked the end of the building: with this sale, the Tribeca tower's sponsor sales are complete, a decade after marketing began.

The price is the story, and it is a story about filed numbers. The developers, the Witkoff Group, Fisher Brothers, and New Valley Ventures, specified $50M for the penthouse in a 2024 amendment to the building's offering plan, up from the $45M they sought when marketing began more than a decade ago. When the apartment finally reached the market in September 2025, it asked just under $34M. It closed at $31M: about 38 percent below the filed figure and about 9 percent below the asking price.

An offering-plan price is a filing, not a forecast.

The building's other penthouse tells the same story. It traded in 2025 for $28M against a $45M plan price, again close to 38 percent below the filed number. Two penthouses, two discounts of nearly the same size, in the same tower: the pattern is not a negotiation quirk but a verdict on the plan prices themselves. The filed figures, set years before the homes were finished — Penthouse 1 was not completed until late summer 2026 — described a market that no longer existed by the time buyers walked through the door.

That is what makes 111 Murray a test case rather than a one-off. The tower, a 157-unit building completed in 2018 on a site the developers bought for $200M in 2013, carried its last unsold homes for years while paying the carrying costs, common charges, taxes, and interest on inventory loans, every month. A developer holding finished, unsold apartments has every reason to close the books, and the last units are where that pressure shows. The discount is the concession a sponsor accepts to retire its final inventory, and it can run well past anything market conditions alone would explain.

The lesson is not that Tribeca penthouses are cheap. $31M is still the week's top deal, and the week's 34 contracts above $4M show the luxury market moving. It is that an offering-plan price is a filing, not a forecast. When a tower's filed prices meet the resale market years later, the market wins, and the gap, 38 percent, twice over, is the measure of how far apart the two can drift.